Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
+3
dbrown4
dboss
bobheckler
7 posters
Page 1 of 1
Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
https://www.nbcsports.com/boston/celtics/lack-depth-and-health-proving-too-much-these-boston-celtics-vs-brooklyn-nets
Forsberg: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
23H AGO
BY CHRIS FORSBERG
CELTICS INSIDER
If we’re being honest, the Boston Celtics breathed about as much excitement as could have been reasonably expected into this series against the Brooklyn Nets.
Jayson Tatum’s thrilling 50-point night in Friday’s Game 3 made us all temporarily forget about the obvious talent disparity in this series. For a solid 48 hours, we talked ourselves into the possibility that Boston could make things even more interesting, especially with 17,226 fans cramming back inside TD Garden on Sunday night.
But that buzz wore off quickly. Kyrie Irving, despite the full-throated boos from the lathered masses, got himself going early in Game 4. The Nets' Big Three combined for 104 points to propel a Brooklyn offense that scored 79 points in the middle quarters and raced away to a 141-126 win and a 3-1 series lead.
The notion that Boston might steal more than a game in this series always seemed unlikely without Jaylen Brown. Then the Celtics lost both Kemba Walker and Robert Williams for Game 4.
Boston’s lack of depth has been on display all season. And while the Nets could lose a Jeff Green and barely miss a beat, the Celtics haven't been able to withstand even a single absence. Without three starters, they had no chance.
And, thus, the 2020-21 season could end as early as Tuesday night in Brooklyn. There is heavy lifting ahead for Danny Ainge this summer to overhaul a flawed roster that limped through a .500 season, stumbled to the 7th seed, and will bow out early in the playoffs.
There will be positives to pluck from this postseason, especially Tatum’s play. He was special in Game 3 with Synergy Sports suggesting he scored 31 of his 50 points in isolation, one of the highest numbers in modern tracking. Tatum hunted mismatches and attacked them, hitting a bevy of tough shots. Sharing the floor with two former MVPs (James Harden, Kevin Durant) and a seven-time All-Star coming off a 50/40/90 season (Irving), Tatum was still the best player on the court. Tatum needed at least one night like that.
The Nets made things more difficult in Game 4 and he still went for 40. He’ll learn from this series, his first postseason series as a lone focal point of the offense, and it will make him better when the Celtics are healthier in future playoffs.
Game 4 belonged to Irving. After looking tentative, and maybe a bit unnerved, during his first visit in front of Boston fans on Friday night, he tried to get himself going early in Game 4. Irving put up 39 points and 11 rebounds.
What happened after the game will, unfortunately, dominate the discussion. A Celtics fan tossed a water bottle at Irving as he departed the court and was arrested by Boston police. He’ll soon have a lifetime ban from TD Garden. It was an unacceptable act and a frustrating one after 17,225 other fans seemingly behaved themselves.
Right before that incident, Irving appeared to stomp on Boston's Lucky the Leprechaun logo at midcourt while congratulating teammates as they departed the court. It wasn’t a particularly egregious moment but unnecessary given the way that Irving performed on the court.
Ultimately, the Celtics have far more pressing issues than a former player rubbing his foot on their logo.
Walker’s struggles in this series and his absence in a pivotal Game 4 will not quiet the cries of those uncertain about his future here. Brad Stevens stressed how hard it was for Walker to be sidelined, a bone bruise on his already sore knee leaving him unable to go, but it will do little to ease concerns about Walker’s ability to stay on the floor moving forward.
Evan Fournier has had his moments in this series but maybe not enough to justify the price tag he could command this summer as an unrestricted free agent. Boston’s interest in retaining him could ultimately hinge on both market price and the other moves the team makes that might ease a ballooning cap sheet.
Some younger players have gotten important playing time in this series. Romeo Langford got the start in Game 4 and those playoff reps defending James Harden will be valuable down the road (NBA tracking data had opponents shooting 5 of 12 against him on Sunday). Rookie Aaron Nesmith hit a trio of 3-pointers while logging 19 minutes. Even late-season addition Jabari Parker showed how he might be able to help this team next year.
But much of the back end of this roster needs to be overhauled. Maybe even more drastic changes await a team where only Tatum and Brown (and Stevens) are certain to be back. Boston’s inability to get consistent play from many of their bench pieces and their overall lack of talent bit them repeatedly this year. An early exit will leave us all wondering if a more robust roster could have at least helped them avoid an unceremonious first-round exit.
Ultimately, even more talent might not have mattered against these Nets, or any of the best teams in the East. Brooklyn shot 57.8 percent overall and 59.3 percent beyond the 3-point line while making 29 of 30 free throws. They had an offensive rating of 143.9 in a playoff game, which is just beyond absurd.
We’re left wondering just how deep the gap is between the Celtics and Nets. It feels like a healthy Brown, Walker, and Williams would have leveled the playing field a bit. But Boston still needs more overall talent to hang, especially with what we’ve seen from the Nets, Sixers, and Bucks this postseason.
There is still basketball to be played this season -- even if it’s just one more game -- but the focus has shifted to what’s ahead. Ainge and Co. have a lot of work in front of them to put the Celtics in position to wash out the taste of a bitter season.
Bob
MY NOTE: You build teams to match up with, and to defeat, your most difficult playoff opponents since they are the ones who are between you and #18. Danny kept Semi because he was/is a good defender vs Giannis. Thompson was a good, rugged rebounder and defender to compete against Embiid and other big centers. The problem is that Sean Marks of the Nets made a bold move this mid-season and leapfrogged us and a lot of other teams. An elite player, James Harden, decided he wanted to leave Houston and Marks pushed a bunch of valuable chips into the middle of the table and went for it while Danny stood pat (to be fair, I seem to remember the sentiment on this board as being against trading for Harden). He picked up what could be a good longtime player in Fournier, but not a game-changer, and nibbled around the edges with Parker but no big moves. He banked on our bench growing up fast. They grew up some, as much as could be expected, but not enough. He bet on the growth of the Js, and was right about that, and he held out for value for Kemba when there wasn't/isn't much when you consider his contract. Now, Danny is behind the 8-ball. Every GM in the league knows about Kemba's delicateness, he will never get real value for him, and if we have Kemba we don't have a Big 3 and you need a Big 3 to win it all in this league now. Can/will Danny trade everybody from #7 on down? Sure, I'm sure he'll try, but can you convince another GM to take a bundle of scrubs to get a clear roster upgrade? Trader Danny got outtraded. My personal view is that, and we've seen this happen with Danny before with Ray Allen and Tony Allen, he got scarred by the Kyrie experience and went overboard the other way. He saw how bad chemistry destroyed that team so he went for chemistry post-Kyrie. He went with everybody's friend Kemba Walker and stuck with players that get along with everybody. He relied upon the recreation of Ubuntu. Ubuntu works but you still need the horses to compete.
.
Forsberg: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
23H AGO
BY CHRIS FORSBERG
CELTICS INSIDER
If we’re being honest, the Boston Celtics breathed about as much excitement as could have been reasonably expected into this series against the Brooklyn Nets.
Jayson Tatum’s thrilling 50-point night in Friday’s Game 3 made us all temporarily forget about the obvious talent disparity in this series. For a solid 48 hours, we talked ourselves into the possibility that Boston could make things even more interesting, especially with 17,226 fans cramming back inside TD Garden on Sunday night.
But that buzz wore off quickly. Kyrie Irving, despite the full-throated boos from the lathered masses, got himself going early in Game 4. The Nets' Big Three combined for 104 points to propel a Brooklyn offense that scored 79 points in the middle quarters and raced away to a 141-126 win and a 3-1 series lead.
The notion that Boston might steal more than a game in this series always seemed unlikely without Jaylen Brown. Then the Celtics lost both Kemba Walker and Robert Williams for Game 4.
Boston’s lack of depth has been on display all season. And while the Nets could lose a Jeff Green and barely miss a beat, the Celtics haven't been able to withstand even a single absence. Without three starters, they had no chance.
And, thus, the 2020-21 season could end as early as Tuesday night in Brooklyn. There is heavy lifting ahead for Danny Ainge this summer to overhaul a flawed roster that limped through a .500 season, stumbled to the 7th seed, and will bow out early in the playoffs.
There will be positives to pluck from this postseason, especially Tatum’s play. He was special in Game 3 with Synergy Sports suggesting he scored 31 of his 50 points in isolation, one of the highest numbers in modern tracking. Tatum hunted mismatches and attacked them, hitting a bevy of tough shots. Sharing the floor with two former MVPs (James Harden, Kevin Durant) and a seven-time All-Star coming off a 50/40/90 season (Irving), Tatum was still the best player on the court. Tatum needed at least one night like that.
The Nets made things more difficult in Game 4 and he still went for 40. He’ll learn from this series, his first postseason series as a lone focal point of the offense, and it will make him better when the Celtics are healthier in future playoffs.
Game 4 belonged to Irving. After looking tentative, and maybe a bit unnerved, during his first visit in front of Boston fans on Friday night, he tried to get himself going early in Game 4. Irving put up 39 points and 11 rebounds.
What happened after the game will, unfortunately, dominate the discussion. A Celtics fan tossed a water bottle at Irving as he departed the court and was arrested by Boston police. He’ll soon have a lifetime ban from TD Garden. It was an unacceptable act and a frustrating one after 17,225 other fans seemingly behaved themselves.
Right before that incident, Irving appeared to stomp on Boston's Lucky the Leprechaun logo at midcourt while congratulating teammates as they departed the court. It wasn’t a particularly egregious moment but unnecessary given the way that Irving performed on the court.
Ultimately, the Celtics have far more pressing issues than a former player rubbing his foot on their logo.
Walker’s struggles in this series and his absence in a pivotal Game 4 will not quiet the cries of those uncertain about his future here. Brad Stevens stressed how hard it was for Walker to be sidelined, a bone bruise on his already sore knee leaving him unable to go, but it will do little to ease concerns about Walker’s ability to stay on the floor moving forward.
Evan Fournier has had his moments in this series but maybe not enough to justify the price tag he could command this summer as an unrestricted free agent. Boston’s interest in retaining him could ultimately hinge on both market price and the other moves the team makes that might ease a ballooning cap sheet.
Some younger players have gotten important playing time in this series. Romeo Langford got the start in Game 4 and those playoff reps defending James Harden will be valuable down the road (NBA tracking data had opponents shooting 5 of 12 against him on Sunday). Rookie Aaron Nesmith hit a trio of 3-pointers while logging 19 minutes. Even late-season addition Jabari Parker showed how he might be able to help this team next year.
But much of the back end of this roster needs to be overhauled. Maybe even more drastic changes await a team where only Tatum and Brown (and Stevens) are certain to be back. Boston’s inability to get consistent play from many of their bench pieces and their overall lack of talent bit them repeatedly this year. An early exit will leave us all wondering if a more robust roster could have at least helped them avoid an unceremonious first-round exit.
Ultimately, even more talent might not have mattered against these Nets, or any of the best teams in the East. Brooklyn shot 57.8 percent overall and 59.3 percent beyond the 3-point line while making 29 of 30 free throws. They had an offensive rating of 143.9 in a playoff game, which is just beyond absurd.
We’re left wondering just how deep the gap is between the Celtics and Nets. It feels like a healthy Brown, Walker, and Williams would have leveled the playing field a bit. But Boston still needs more overall talent to hang, especially with what we’ve seen from the Nets, Sixers, and Bucks this postseason.
There is still basketball to be played this season -- even if it’s just one more game -- but the focus has shifted to what’s ahead. Ainge and Co. have a lot of work in front of them to put the Celtics in position to wash out the taste of a bitter season.
Bob
MY NOTE: You build teams to match up with, and to defeat, your most difficult playoff opponents since they are the ones who are between you and #18. Danny kept Semi because he was/is a good defender vs Giannis. Thompson was a good, rugged rebounder and defender to compete against Embiid and other big centers. The problem is that Sean Marks of the Nets made a bold move this mid-season and leapfrogged us and a lot of other teams. An elite player, James Harden, decided he wanted to leave Houston and Marks pushed a bunch of valuable chips into the middle of the table and went for it while Danny stood pat (to be fair, I seem to remember the sentiment on this board as being against trading for Harden). He picked up what could be a good longtime player in Fournier, but not a game-changer, and nibbled around the edges with Parker but no big moves. He banked on our bench growing up fast. They grew up some, as much as could be expected, but not enough. He bet on the growth of the Js, and was right about that, and he held out for value for Kemba when there wasn't/isn't much when you consider his contract. Now, Danny is behind the 8-ball. Every GM in the league knows about Kemba's delicateness, he will never get real value for him, and if we have Kemba we don't have a Big 3 and you need a Big 3 to win it all in this league now. Can/will Danny trade everybody from #7 on down? Sure, I'm sure he'll try, but can you convince another GM to take a bundle of scrubs to get a clear roster upgrade? Trader Danny got outtraded. My personal view is that, and we've seen this happen with Danny before with Ray Allen and Tony Allen, he got scarred by the Kyrie experience and went overboard the other way. He saw how bad chemistry destroyed that team so he went for chemistry post-Kyrie. He went with everybody's friend Kemba Walker and stuck with players that get along with everybody. He relied upon the recreation of Ubuntu. Ubuntu works but you still need the horses to compete.
.
bobheckler- Posts : 62581
Join date : 2009-10-28
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
Can we just hold our horses before crowning the Nets?
dboss- Posts : 19217
Join date : 2009-11-01
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
dboss,
I'm willing to let the horses go to guarantee a Bucks beat down of the Nets next round.
db
I'm willing to let the horses go to guarantee a Bucks beat down of the Nets next round.
db
dbrown4- Posts : 5611
Join date : 2009-10-29
Age : 61
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
A lot of good points Bob and maybe I am missing something here but I don’t think you build teams to match up with and defeat your most difficult playoff opponents. That’s game board mentality.bobheckler wrote:https://www.nbcsports.com/boston/celtics/lack-depth-and-health-proving-too-much-these-boston-celtics-vs-brooklyn-nets
Forsberg: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
23H AGO
BY CHRIS FORSBERG
CELTICS INSIDER
If we’re being honest, the Boston Celtics breathed about as much excitement as could have been reasonably expected into this series against the Brooklyn Nets.
Jayson Tatum’s thrilling 50-point night in Friday’s Game 3 made us all temporarily forget about the obvious talent disparity in this series. For a solid 48 hours, we talked ourselves into the possibility that Boston could make things even more interesting, especially with 17,226 fans cramming back inside TD Garden on Sunday night.
But that buzz wore off quickly. Kyrie Irving, despite the full-throated boos from the lathered masses, got himself going early in Game 4. The Nets' Big Three combined for 104 points to propel a Brooklyn offense that scored 79 points in the middle quarters and raced away to a 141-126 win and a 3-1 series lead.
The notion that Boston might steal more than a game in this series always seemed unlikely without Jaylen Brown. Then the Celtics lost both Kemba Walker and Robert Williams for Game 4.
Boston’s lack of depth has been on display all season. And while the Nets could lose a Jeff Green and barely miss a beat, the Celtics haven't been able to withstand even a single absence. Without three starters, they had no chance.
And, thus, the 2020-21 season could end as early as Tuesday night in Brooklyn. There is heavy lifting ahead for Danny Ainge this summer to overhaul a flawed roster that limped through a .500 season, stumbled to the 7th seed, and will bow out early in the playoffs.
There will be positives to pluck from this postseason, especially Tatum’s play. He was special in Game 3 with Synergy Sports suggesting he scored 31 of his 50 points in isolation, one of the highest numbers in modern tracking. Tatum hunted mismatches and attacked them, hitting a bevy of tough shots. Sharing the floor with two former MVPs (James Harden, Kevin Durant) and a seven-time All-Star coming off a 50/40/90 season (Irving), Tatum was still the best player on the court. Tatum needed at least one night like that.
The Nets made things more difficult in Game 4 and he still went for 40. He’ll learn from this series, his first postseason series as a lone focal point of the offense, and it will make him better when the Celtics are healthier in future playoffs.
Game 4 belonged to Irving. After looking tentative, and maybe a bit unnerved, during his first visit in front of Boston fans on Friday night, he tried to get himself going early in Game 4. Irving put up 39 points and 11 rebounds.
What happened after the game will, unfortunately, dominate the discussion. A Celtics fan tossed a water bottle at Irving as he departed the court and was arrested by Boston police. He’ll soon have a lifetime ban from TD Garden. It was an unacceptable act and a frustrating one after 17,225 other fans seemingly behaved themselves.
Right before that incident, Irving appeared to stomp on Boston's Lucky the Leprechaun logo at midcourt while congratulating teammates as they departed the court. It wasn’t a particularly egregious moment but unnecessary given the way that Irving performed on the court.
Ultimately, the Celtics have far more pressing issues than a former player rubbing his foot on their logo.
Walker’s struggles in this series and his absence in a pivotal Game 4 will not quiet the cries of those uncertain about his future here. Brad Stevens stressed how hard it was for Walker to be sidelined, a bone bruise on his already sore knee leaving him unable to go, but it will do little to ease concerns about Walker’s ability to stay on the floor moving forward.
Evan Fournier has had his moments in this series but maybe not enough to justify the price tag he could command this summer as an unrestricted free agent. Boston’s interest in retaining him could ultimately hinge on both market price and the other moves the team makes that might ease a ballooning cap sheet.
Some younger players have gotten important playing time in this series. Romeo Langford got the start in Game 4 and those playoff reps defending James Harden will be valuable down the road (NBA tracking data had opponents shooting 5 of 12 against him on Sunday). Rookie Aaron Nesmith hit a trio of 3-pointers while logging 19 minutes. Even late-season addition Jabari Parker showed how he might be able to help this team next year.
But much of the back end of this roster needs to be overhauled. Maybe even more drastic changes await a team where only Tatum and Brown (and Stevens) are certain to be back. Boston’s inability to get consistent play from many of their bench pieces and their overall lack of talent bit them repeatedly this year. An early exit will leave us all wondering if a more robust roster could have at least helped them avoid an unceremonious first-round exit.
Ultimately, even more talent might not have mattered against these Nets, or any of the best teams in the East. Brooklyn shot 57.8 percent overall and 59.3 percent beyond the 3-point line while making 29 of 30 free throws. They had an offensive rating of 143.9 in a playoff game, which is just beyond absurd.
We’re left wondering just how deep the gap is between the Celtics and Nets. It feels like a healthy Brown, Walker, and Williams would have leveled the playing field a bit. But Boston still needs more overall talent to hang, especially with what we’ve seen from the Nets, Sixers, and Bucks this postseason.
There is still basketball to be played this season -- even if it’s just one more game -- but the focus has shifted to what’s ahead. Ainge and Co. have a lot of work in front of them to put the Celtics in position to wash out the taste of a bitter season.
Bob
MY NOTE: You build teams to match up with, and to defeat, your most difficult playoff opponents since they are the ones who are between you and #18. Danny kept Semi because he was/is a good defender vs Giannis. Thompson was a good, rugged rebounder and defender to compete against Embiid and other big centers. The problem is that Sean Marks of the Nets made a bold move this mid-season and leapfrogged us and a lot of other teams. An elite player, James Harden, decided he wanted to leave Houston and Marks pushed a bunch of valuable chips into the middle of the table and went for it while Danny stood pat (to be fair, I seem to remember the sentiment on this board as being against trading for Harden). He picked up what could be a good longtime player in Fournier, but not a game-changer, and nibbled around the edges with Parker but no big moves. He banked on our bench growing up fast. They grew up some, as much as could be expected, but not enough. He bet on the growth of the Js, and was right about that, and he held out for value for Kemba when there wasn't/isn't much when you consider his contract. Now, Danny is behind the 8-ball. Every GM in the league knows about Kemba's delicateness, he will never get real value for him, and if we have Kemba we don't have a Big 3 and you need a Big 3 to win it all in this league now. Can/will Danny trade everybody from #7 on down? Sure, I'm sure he'll try, but can you convince another GM to take a bundle of scrubs to get a clear roster upgrade? Trader Danny got outtraded. My personal view is that, and we've seen this happen with Danny before with Ray Allen and Tony Allen, he got scarred by the Kyrie experience and went overboard the other way. He saw how bad chemistry destroyed that team so he went for chemistry post-Kyrie. He went with everybody's friend Kemba Walker and stuck with players that get along with everybody. He relied upon the recreation of Ubuntu. Ubuntu works but you still need the horses to compete.
.
I believe you strategically add/subtract 1-2 (most 3) specific players that match up well with said difficult opponent but you build your entire team to the win against any team you face in this league. You build the best team and the rest takes care of itself.
Last edited by Ktron on Tue Jun 01, 2021 12:56 pm; edited 1 time in total
Ktron- Posts : 8378
Join date : 2014-01-22
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
dboss wrote:Can we just hold our horses before crowning the Nets?
Good point.Lets just end the season now.Why waste anymore time when we know what the outcome is going to be.
“Crown em”
-Dennis Green (R.I.P)
Ktron- Posts : 8378
Join date : 2014-01-22
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
Ktron wrote:dboss wrote:Can we just hold our horses before crowning the Nets?
Good point.Lets just end the season now.Why waste anymore time when we know what the outcome is going to be.
“Crown em”
-Dennis Green (R.I.P)
"That's why they play the games."
- Chris Berman
NYCelt- Posts : 10794
Join date : 2009-10-12
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
And you are right, dboss. We should play the game. And if it so happens that Boston wins this game tonight in Brooklyn, I will have no option but to put you on the same pedestal right next to Sam. Now in my humble but accurate opinion, you are already there regardless of tonight's outcome but this would be the icing on the cake as well as well-deserved and earned mud in the face of those like myself that have unfortunately given up hope this season.
I do seem to remember a game in the late 60's where no one gave us a chance in a Game 7 away from home and had already thrown dirt on the grave....(or balloons in the rafters...something like that, I can't remember!)
Thank you for always being the voice of reason in a completely unreasonable season!
db
I do seem to remember a game in the late 60's where no one gave us a chance in a Game 7 away from home and had already thrown dirt on the grave....(or balloons in the rafters...something like that, I can't remember!)
Thank you for always being the voice of reason in a completely unreasonable season!
db
dbrown4- Posts : 5611
Join date : 2009-10-29
Age : 61
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
I love Forsberg but really, I do not need an illustration from the Nets to tell me how far the Celtics have to go. That was made blatantly obvious by the Celtics play throughout the season!
And the talk that maybe the Celtic could pick-up a win or two in the series............STOP I do not give a crap! Spare me the melodrama, please sweep the series and get on to next season!
And again reflecting on Brad's High Praise of the Nets speech a week back, saying how great a team they are............................HEY BRAD HOW ABOUT STOP FOCUSING ON HOW GOOD THE NETS ARE....................HOW ABOUT FOCUSING ON A LOCK DOWN DEFENSIVE STRATEGY!
If you did and the team did not carry out your game plan, that tells me you are toast as a coach! You have lost the respect of the team!
112288
And the talk that maybe the Celtic could pick-up a win or two in the series............STOP I do not give a crap! Spare me the melodrama, please sweep the series and get on to next season!
And again reflecting on Brad's High Praise of the Nets speech a week back, saying how great a team they are............................HEY BRAD HOW ABOUT STOP FOCUSING ON HOW GOOD THE NETS ARE....................HOW ABOUT FOCUSING ON A LOCK DOWN DEFENSIVE STRATEGY!
If you did and the team did not carry out your game plan, that tells me you are toast as a coach! You have lost the respect of the team!
112288
112288- Posts : 7855
Join date : 2009-10-17
Re: Nets illustrate how far the Celtics still have to go
Go Suns. Go Bucks. See ya next year, Celts.
jrleftfoot- Posts : 2085
Join date : 2016-07-08
Similar topics
» ESPN "experts" picks Celtics- Nets VS Sam's Celtics Forum
» Report: Nets Lost $144 Million, Celtics Made $33.1 Million Read more at: http://nesn.com/2014/06/report-brooklyn-nets-projected-to-net-loss-of-144-million-in-2013-14/
» Nets/Celtics 10/15
» That's What He Said - Celtics @ Nets
» Celtics vs Nets
» Report: Nets Lost $144 Million, Celtics Made $33.1 Million Read more at: http://nesn.com/2014/06/report-brooklyn-nets-projected-to-net-loss-of-144-million-in-2013-14/
» Nets/Celtics 10/15
» That's What He Said - Celtics @ Nets
» Celtics vs Nets
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum